Understanding Withdrawal Rates and Retirement Longevity
What is a Withdrawal Rate in Plain Language?
A withdrawal rate is the percentage of your retirement portfolio that you withdraw each year to cover living expenses. For example, if you have $1,000,000 saved and withdraw $40,000 in the first year, your initial withdrawal rate is 4%. The challenge in retirement is finding a withdrawal rate that allows your portfolio to last throughout your retirement while maintaining your desired lifestyle. Too high a withdrawal rate can deplete your portfolio too quickly, while too low a rate might mean you're not using your savings effectively.
How This Simulator Approximates Retirement Longevity
This simulator uses a simplified model that assumes a single constant annual return and a single inflation rate. Each year, it: (1) Withdraws a fixed amount (or inflation-adjusted amount, or percentage of balance, depending on your chosen pattern), (2) Applies the expected return to the remaining balance, and (3) Tracks how the portfolio balance changes over time. It continues until the portfolio is depleted or reaches the maximum simulation years. This is a deterministic projection—it shows one possible path under constant assumptions, not a range of outcomes or probabilities.
Why Constant-Return Projections are Very Limited
Real markets are volatile and unpredictable. Some years see large gains (20%+), others see losses (-30% or more). The sequence of returns matters greatly—a portfolio that experiences losses early in retirement can deplete much faster than one that experiences losses later, even if the average return is the same. This simulator uses a constant return assumption, which means it doesn't capture: Market volatility: Real returns fluctuate significantly from year to year. Sequence-of-returns risk: The order of good and bad years matters. Bear markets: Extended downturns can significantly impact portfolio longevity. Uncertainty: Future returns are unknown and unpredictable. This is why the tool emphasizes it's educational only and not a guarantee.
What the Classic '4% Rule' Idea is at a High Level (Without Endorsing It)
The "4% rule" is a popular but simplified retirement withdrawal guideline. It suggests withdrawing 4% of your initial retirement portfolio in the first year, then adjusting that amount for inflation each subsequent year. The idea is that this pattern might sustain a 30-year retirement in many historical scenarios based on backtesting. However, the 4% rule is not a guarantee—it's based on historical data and assumptions that may not hold in the future. It doesn't account for taxes, fees, personal circumstances, or future market conditions. This simulator can help you explore 4%-style withdrawal patterns, but it does not endorse or guarantee the rule. Real retirement planning should consider many factors beyond a simple percentage rule.
Important Things This Tool Does NOT Model (Volatility, Sequence Risk, Taxes, RMDs, etc.)
This simulator is a simplified educational tool and does not account for many real-world factors: Market Volatility: It uses a constant return, not real market fluctuations. Sequence-of-Returns Risk: The order of good and bad years can significantly impact portfolio longevity, but this tool doesn't model that. Taxes: It does not model taxes on withdrawals, capital gains, dividends, or required minimum distributions (RMDs). Account Rules: It doesn't consider 401(k), IRA, or other account-specific rules and restrictions. Trading Costs: Fees, bid-ask spreads, and transaction costs are not included. Healthcare and Insurance: Medical expenses, long-term care, and insurance costs are not modeled. Unexpected Expenses: Emergencies, major repairs, or other unplanned costs are not considered. Personal Circumstances: Your health, family situation, goals, and other personal factors are not included. Always consider these factors when making real retirement decisions.
Note: This simulator is for educational purposes only and does not provide personalized financial, tax, or retirement advice. It does not predict future market performance or guarantee any outcomes. It does not recommend specific withdrawal rates or strategies. Always consult with qualified financial advisors, tax professionals, and review official plan documents for personalized retirement planning.
Frequently Asked Questions
Related Tools
Retirement Savings Calculator
Estimate how much you might have by retirement and how that compares with your desired income
FIRE Calculator
Estimate how long it might take to reach financial independence based on savings, returns, spending, and withdrawal rate
Investment Growth Calculator
Project how an investment or portfolio could grow over time with contributions and expected returns
Investment Fees Impact Calculator
Estimate how ongoing investment fees might reduce your portfolio's future value compared with a no-fee baseline
Taxable vs Tax-Advantaged Comparison
Compare how money might grow in a taxable account versus a tax-advantaged account using simple tax assumptions